CSEC BIOLOGY · SECTION C · LESSON C6

Species, Speciation and Natural Selection

What a species is, how new species form, Darwin’s theory of natural selection with Caribbean and modern examples, and natural vs artificial selection.

Continuity and VariationSO C 4.1SO C 4.2SO C 5.1SO C 5.2≈ 35 min🎮 3 games
Before you start

By the end of this lesson you can…

Step 1 · Watch

Explainer video

5 narrated scenes. Press play, listen and read along — the points appear as they are explained. Use ‹ Prev / Next › or the scene bar to jump to any scene.

LESSON C6 · EXPLAINER

Species, Speciation and Natural Selection

Anole lizards on different Caribbean islands look remarkably alike — yet they evolved separately. How?

Narration uses your device’s built-in voice. No sound? Switch to “Captions only” — the captions advance on their own.

Step 2 · Read

Key notes

Copy these into your notebook in your own words — that is how they stick.

Species

Organisms that can interbreed under natural conditions to produce fertile offspring.

Natural selection

Variation → overproduction → competition → survival of best adapted → reproduction → change in allele frequency.

Evidence/examples

Peppered moth, antibiotic resistance, pesticide resistance, Galapagos finches, Caribbean anoles.

Speciation

Geographical isolation (allopatric) or reproductive isolation (sympatric) → populations diverge → cannot interbreed.

Artificial selection

Humans breed organisms with desired traits; faster; reduces variation.

Advantages of natural selection

Adaptation to environment; biodiversity; survival of species.

Disadvantages

Slow; less-adapted individuals die; can produce resistant pests/pathogens that harm humans.

EXAM TIPS & COMMON MISTAKES

  • Darwin’s theory in 2 marks: variation + survival of the best adapted who reproduce and pass on alleles.
  • Antibiotic resistance: mutation gives resistance → antibiotic kills non-resistant → resistant survive & multiply.
  • Natural selection “produces great biological diversity”; artificial “produces organisms very different from natural populations” (P1).
Step 2 · Learn from examples

Worked examples & study resources

The kind of support a teacher gives after the lesson: worked examples to attempt first, a board illustration, key terms, common misconceptions and memory aids.

Worked example 1

Mosquitoes that resist insecticide

After years of spraying with the same insecticide, a health department finds that it no longer kills many of the mosquitoes in an area. Use natural selection to explain why.

Try it in your notebook first, then reveal the solution one step at a time.

  1. Variation: in the original mosquito population a few individuals carried an allele (from a random mutation) that made them resistant to the insecticide.
  2. Selection pressure: spraying killed most of the non-resistant mosquitoes.
  3. Survival: the resistant mosquitoes survived because they were better adapted to the new environment.
  4. Reproduction: the survivors bred and passed the resistance allele to their offspring.
  5. Over many generations the proportion of resistant mosquitoes increased until most of the population was resistant.
Answer. Random mutation gave a few mosquitoes resistance; spraying killed the others; resistant survivors reproduced and passed on the allele, so over many generations the population became resistant.
Examiner’s tip. The insecticide did not CAUSE the resistance — it selected mosquitoes that already had it. Saying “the mosquitoes adapted to the poison” loses the mark.
Worked example 2

How new species of anole lizards formed

Different species of anole lizard live on different Caribbean islands. Suggest how one ancestral species could have given rise to several species.

Try it in your notebook first, then reveal the solution one step at a time.

  1. Isolation: a few lizards reached different islands (for example on floating vegetation) and the sea kept the populations apart — no interbreeding.
  2. Different conditions: each island had different habitats, food and predators — different selection pressures.
  3. Natural selection favoured different features on each island (body size, leg length, colour), and mutations arose independently in each population.
  4. Over many generations the populations became so different genetically that, even if they met, they could no longer interbreed to produce fertile offspring — they had become separate species.
Answer. Geographical isolation on separate islands → different selection pressures and mutations → populations change genetically → eventually cannot interbreed to produce fertile offspring → new species.
Examiner’s tip. The key ideas are isolation (no gene flow), different selection pressures, and the final test of a new species: cannot produce fertile offspring together.
On the board · Natural selection step by step
Variationindividuals differ; some due to mutation↓Over-productionmore young than can survive↓Competitionfor food, mates, space↓Survival of the best adaptedothers die↓Reproductionuseful alleles passed on↓Over generationspopulation changes

Write these five ideas in order and you have the core of any natural selection answer.

Key terms

Species
A group of organisms that can interbreed to produce fertile offspring.
Natural selection
Better-adapted individuals survive and reproduce more, passing on their alleles.
Adaptation
A feature that helps an organism survive in its environment.
Selection pressure
A factor (predator, disease, climate, poison) that affects which individuals survive.
Speciation
The formation of a new species.
Geographical isolation
Populations separated by a physical barrier such as the sea or a mountain.
Artificial selection
Humans choosing which individuals breed, to get desired features.

Common misconceptions

  • ✗ Individual organisms adapt during their lifetime.✓ Populations change over many generations; an individual’s genes do not change because it needs them to.
  • ✗ “Survival of the fittest” means the strongest survive.✓ “Fittest” means best adapted to the environment — which may mean smallest, best camouflaged or most drought-tolerant.
  • ✗ Organisms develop resistance because they need it.✓ Resistance arises by random mutation; selection then increases its frequency.

Memory aid

Natural selection in five words: Variation, Over-production, Competition, Survival, Reproduction — “VOCS-R”.

Real-life link

Aedes aegypti mosquitoes in many Caribbean countries have become resistant to some common insecticides. Public health teams test for resistance and switch between insecticides — natural selection is a real problem in disease control.

Try this

Scatter 20 green and 20 brown paper “insects” on a lawn. Give a friend 30 seconds to pick up as many as they can. Which colour survived better? Repeat on bare soil.

Play & practise

Games

3 quick games on this lesson. Earn XP and badges as you play — your best score for each game is saved. Games are for practice and do not change your exam readiness.

Step 3 · Practise

Paper 1 practice — multiple choice

8 items modelled on real CSEC Paper 1 questions. Choose one answer for each, then check. Aim for 80% or better.

Adapted from CSEC P1 2022 Item 58; 2023 Item 58

1. A species consists of members that

Answer: B. Standard species definition.
Adapted from CSEC P1 2022, 2023, 2024 Item 59

2. Which description is true of natural and artificial selection?

Answer: C. Humans drive AS; the environment drives NS.
Syllabus suggested activity 6 (Mr Farmer’s shed)

3. Insecticide sprayed repeatedly on flies becomes less effective because

Answer: A. Selection for resistance alleles.
EduTech practice item (SO C4.2)

4. Speciation by geographical isolation requires

Answer: A. Separated populations diverge.
Based on CSEC P2 January 2026, Q4(d)

5. Which is an example of artificial selection?

Answer: D. Humans chose the trait.
EduTech practice item

6. In natural selection, the organisms MOST likely to survive are those that

Answer: C. “Survival of the fittest” = best adapted.
EduTech practice item

7. A horse and a donkey produce an infertile mule. This shows horses and donkeys are

Answer: D. Offspring are not fertile.
Based on CSEC P2 May/June 2021, Q6(b)

8. Antibiotic resistance in bacteria is an example of

Answer: B. The antibiotic is the selection pressure.
Step 4 · Apply

Paper 2 practice — structured questions

Write full answers, then reveal the mark scheme and tick the points you earned (24 marks in total). Your answers are saved on this device.

Based on CSEC P2 May/June 2021, Question 6

Question 1 [9 marks]

Natural selection and artificial selection.

(a) Outline Darwin’s theory of natural selection. [2]

MARK SCHEME — (a) (max 2)

(b) Explain why the development of antibiotic resistance in bacteria is an example of natural selection. [2]

MARK SCHEME — (b) (max 2)

(c) Suggest TWO ways artificial selection benefits a farmer. [2]

MARK SCHEME — (c) (max 2)

(d) Toxic toads were introduced to an island of iguanas. Many iguanas that ate them died; years later adult tail length had increased by 10%. Suggest THREE reasons. [3]

MARK SCHEME — (d) (max 3)

Based on CSEC P2 January 2022, Question 5

Question 2 [15 marks]

Species and speciation.

(a) Using TWO examples, define the term “species”. [4]

MARK SCHEME — (a) (max 4)

(b) State TWO ways speciation occurs and explain how each leads to a new species. [6]

MARK SCHEME — (b) (max 6)

(c) Outline THREE advantages and TWO disadvantages of natural selection. [5]

MARK SCHEME — (c) (max 5)

Your progress

Lesson readiness

0%
READY
Not started
Video watched (20%)0%
Multiple choice (40%)0%
Structured (40%)0%

Sources

Where this topic appears in CSEC papers

Find these in your own past-paper booklets for extra timed practice. The practice above is adapted from them.